Rename Active status and call it Graduated
Status | RESOLVED |
Blocking | |
Outcome | Approved: 9 in favor, 4 abstains. |
Minutes Link |
Overview of Proposal
CNCF has very similar phases for its projects to what we have at Hyperledger but they use the term "Graduated" instead of "Active" after incubation. As we all know, the term "Active" has been a source of confusion for a long time and the term Graduated is a much better name. Using Graduated would end the confusion we have with Active and besides the initial cost of switching - updating all the docs, etc - there doesn't seem to be any downsides.
Formal Proposal(s)
Rename Active status and call it Graduated. Retain a reference to Active as the former name. Clearly specify that Graduated stands for "Graduated from Incubation" and not "Graduated from Labs" to avoid confusion.
Action Items
Update all documentation and the website accordingly
Reviewed By
Angelo de Caro
Arnaud J LE HORS
Arun S M
Baohua Yang
Bobbi Muscara
Danno Ferrin
David Enyeart
Gari Singh
Grace Hartley (Deactivated)
Hart Montgomery
María Teresa nieto
Mark Wagner (Deactivated)
Nathan George
Tracy Kuhrt (Deactivated)
Troy Ronda
"Graduated" is probably a better term given how things have ended up in HL. I still think that too big of a deal is made about "status" in the context of whether or not people will consume / use projects.