2019-09-11-A Aries Working Group Call (US morning)

Summary:

Planned topics

• Continue the discussion of an Aries core library / Indy split until we have a plan that we can work together to implement.

Note: This call is Recorded. Recordings posted at the bottom of the page.

Date

11 Sep 2019 (7AM Los Angeles, 10AM New York, 3PM London, 17H Moscow)

Remember the Hyperledger Code of Conduct

Anti-Trust Policy:

Linux Foundation meetings involve participation by industry competitors, and it is the intention of the Linux Foundation to conduct all of its activities in accordance with applicable antitrust and competition laws. It is therefore extremely important that attendees adhere to meeting agendas, and be aware of, and not participate in any activities that are prohibited under applicable US state, federal or foreign antitrust and competition laws.

Examples of types of actions that are prohibited at Linux Foundation meetings and in connection with Linux Foundation activities are described in the Linux Foundation Antitrust Policy available at http://www.linuxfoundation.org/antitrust-policy. If you have questions about these matters, please contact your company counsel, or if you are a member of the Linux Foundation, feel free to contact Andrew Updegrove of the firm of Gesmer Updegrove LLP, which provides legal counsel to the Linux Foundation.

Attendees

• Name (organization) <email>
• John Callahan (Veridium) <jcallahan@veridiumid.com>
• Ken Ebert (Sovrin Foundation) <ken@sovrin.org>
• Richard Esplin (Evernym)
• Sam Smith (ProSapien) <sam@samuelsmith.org>
• Troy Ronda  (SecureKey) <troy.ronda@securekey.com>
• Stephen Curran (Cloud Compass/BC Gov) <swcurran@cloudcompass.ca>
• Mike Lodder (Sovrin Foundation) <mike@sovrin.org>

Welcome / Introductions

Announcements

• Community project: Aries RFCs - process to move HIPES; RFCs that have been moved concepts / features / pull requests.
• Aries Workshop/Connectathon December 3-5 in Provo, Utah (details to follow)
• IIW
• Hyperledger Maintainers Conference: Minneapolis in October.
• Bootcamp Russia: Event Location

Summary of Prior Calls and Related Meetings

• Aries WG
• Indy
• Ursa
  • Question for the Indy team on testing and deploying debian packages

Release Status

• Aries-CloudAgent-Python (bc.gov) - Release 0.3.2 has been tagged and is on PyPi
  • Support for 0036 and 0037 Credential Exchange protocols, 0.1 version of those protocols deprecated
  • Working on next release, particularly on revocation support.
• Aries-Framework-Go (Troy)
  • First milestone: Framework Go v0.1.0
  • Weekly planning notes
• Aries-SDK-Ruby (Jack)
  • Released as a Gem (0.0.3) due to Rails 6 issues
  • Developed docker image with Rails 6 (Ruby 2.5.1) with Indy-SDK to test Aries-SDK-Ruby via Dokku deployment
  • Needed for exploring concurrency and compatibility issues with Sidekiq, Resque, SuckerPunch, etc.
• Aries-Framework-DotNet (Tomislav)
  • Moved from StreetCred to Aries: https://github.com/hyperledger/aries-framework-dotnet
• Aries-StaticAgent-Python - Release 0.4.0
  • Move from Pysodium → PyNacl
  • Improved module interface and routing.
• Aries-SDK-Python - Wrapper from JeromK and SBCA?
• Aries-SDK-Java
  • People are expressing interest in Rocket Chat, but no one has started contributing code yet. Could start by moving the Indy SDK wrapper to Aries.
• Aries-SDK-JavaScript
  • Need a reviewer for the pull request moving code from Indy-SDK to Aries.
• Indy
• Ursa
  • Working on release of 0.2.0 (September / October)
    • ZKP  / ZKLang improvements
    • Debian packages
    • Refactor internal plumbing for anoncreds 2.0, shouldn't impact external interfaces
    • Refactor multi-signature BLS in addition to aggregated signature
  • Sovrin Foundation is looking to build a Indy specific Ursa,  with ZKPs. Other Aries clients would build a different Ursa.

Work Updates

• Rich Schemas and W3C Verifiable Credentials (Ken)
  • Working on context object in Node. PR for Indy-Node is almost ready for review.
  • Making progress on the new schema object.
  • In order to do the review, need new Indy HIPEs: each new object, the new flow for creating credentials, creation of presentation request and presentation, compatibility with the old credential format
• SDK 2.0 architecture / Indy-Aries split (Sergey)
  • http://jira.hyperledger.org/browse/IS-1285
  • https://docs.google.com/document/d/1MYMi4NkixfoIJeC79WBOfX_QA3_9rG-iK3lZa86vIR0/edit#heading=h.z1u0dzf62loi POA and discussion
  • https://docs.google.com/drawings/d/1d-aCRC_Nzyywv9nyQif9_vBGbeWhp69M4T5_8_yYtAI/edit?usp=sharing Indy SDK Migration box diagram
  • https://docs.google.com/drawings/d/1sUffkRPlufingeeRjjBniVt9Ek3CNih9lUqym8mUl4M/edit?usp=sharing Aries Architecture
  • https://hackmd.io/_BhJewTlSUqMGNDc4SvgNw?edit developing ideas around APIs
  • Aries Presentations
  • https://hackmd.io/@gjPgYQjMT3azdpSAFgo5PA/HyjVdhVGr Daniel B's proposal for separating wallet and crypto
  • https://docs.google.com/document/d/18kHgTsHkSIIW9cakbampv8rxKxNchWycthHnXGyxkls/edit# Daniel H's analysis of challenges and approaches
• Aries Anoncreds Framework

RFC Progress

Other Business

• What is the next step we can take:
  • Order of work
    • Move Indy-SDK into Aries-Core (October release)
    • Split out wallet into Aries-Wallet (November release)
    • Define the resolver interface (November effort)
    • Split out resolver into Indy-Resolver (December release)
  • Questions
    • Iterative approach: do something that we can improve on.
    • Maintain Indy-SDK alongside Aries-Core / Aries-Wallet / Aries-Resolver?
    • Who will be the maintainers of the new libraries? Do we want cross-organization PR reviews?
    • Best way to maintain history, and  make the reorg transparent (concerns with old DCO process).
    • What to do with the Indy CLI?
    • CI / CD in Jenkins or GitLab?
• Architecture of Aries core library
  • What is our fastest path to a library that framework implementors could consider using?
  • Daniel's analysis of Aries API Surfaces https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1ODtHCeB6x7yVGfhyJHFUKn0f070sqZXhff1C8M7jfTY/edit?ts=5d658905#slide=id.p
  • Background in previous meetings: July 31, August 14
  • Progress of Ken's POC
  • Key questions: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1w_n8EztyLbNlRa3FfuuN8YXKUISYRfM5p_6ijIig6jk/edit#

Future Topics

• Next call
• Other:
  • Hubs vs Agents
  • Payments in Aries
  • wallet query language
  • IOT best practices (Robert Mitwicki, Adam Burdett , Lohan Spies )
  • DID Resolution W3C and Sam's concerns: https://github.com/hyperledger/aries-rfcs/issues/130

Action items

• Schedule a deep dive into Aries / Indy architecture (Ken / Richard)

Call Recording